By the time it was all said and done, counting the advice I got on Facebook and comments here on my blog, the overwhelming favorite toilet tissue was Scott's 1000, so I bought some. My other TP finally ran out and the test started.
The first thing I learned about this tissue is that you had better start with a yard of it; for a big job, probably two yards. It's really thin.
But it's tough. I decided I liked it, but would Cliff? His bathroom still had a couple of rolls of the old stuff, so I had to wait to find out.
After three days of testing Scotts 1000, it's a winner in Cliff's bathroom, too. Now, there are some things you don't need a lot of detail on, so I won't tell you all the reasons why he likes it. We do both agree that you don't have to worry about your fingers poking through it at inconvenient times. Enough said.
Despite using over a yard at a time, I'm still using the same roll I initiated five days ago.
Consumer Reports doesn't like this TP, but we're giving it a big thumbs-up. Oh, and the bonus is that this one is the best for your septic tank, if you have one.